Showing posts with label Carole Matthews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Carole Matthews. Show all posts

Monday, 29 November 2010

A Minor Indiscretion (Carole Matthews)***

Ali has been married to Ed for years and she’s always thought she was happy. But when handsome young artist Christian falls in love with her, she’s more than a little bit flattered. Christian is nearly young enough to be her son yet he makes her feel beautiful and loved.

When Ed finds out, he’s just a little bit miffed and kicks Ali out - although one benefit of the new arrangement is that at least he doesn’t have to be quite so embarrassed about his own feelings for his scary workmate Orla. And come to think about it, his youngest son Elliott’s nursery school teacher Nicola is kind of hot too.

Meanwhile Ali sets up home with Christian and his young housemates Robbie and Rebecca, who happens to be Christian’s ex-girlfriend. Christian is kind and sweet and attentive and although he is just a big kid, he does make Ali feel very happy. In addition, Ed’s brother Neil is trying and failing to chat up Ali’s sister Jemma, even though she prefers married men.

In many ways, this book was great. I love the idea of a thirty-eight year old mother of three sharing a house with her toy boy and his mates. I also love how all the single woman around seem to be throwing themselves at Ed now he’s newly single. It was also quite hilarious the way Neil and Jemma clearly liked each other a lot but keep fucking things up.

But I wanted to see more. I wanted to see more of Ali trying her best to get on with Robbie and Rebecca, two people who are completely unlike her, rather than just telling us that Robbie was okay and Rebecca was a bitch. I actually thought Rebecca was mostly amazingly nice to her under the circumstances. How would you feel if you were woken up in the middle of the night by the girlfriend of the man you love needing a place to stay? I think it says a lot for Rebecca that she didn’t kick her out onto the street there and then.

It’s an amazing and original situation with the potential to be really hilarious, as well as giving some very different people the chance to get to know and learn to appreciate each other. But there just wasn’t enough of the parts of the book that interested me most. The book does have some absolutely hilarious moments but I couldn’t help feeling that Carole Matthews missed an opportunity here.

Then towards the end, something really major and shocking and life-changing happens and in a way it spoiled the book. First of all, this book is a comedy – it has some underlying serious messages in it but on the surface, it’s a very funny comedy. So to bring this big event in near the end seemed really inappropriate and strange when you’ve spent five-sixths of the book laughing.

Secondly, this big event is key in helping the characters to decide what they want from life. This is fine and realistic. But I kind of feel the end of the book should be about the characters’ working out what they really want and although it’s not unrealistic that it should take something really major to help them decide this, it does in a way make everything else in the book irrelevant. This big event means it doesn’t matter what they’ve learned about themselves and other people. All that matters in the end is who copes best in a crisis. And I don’t see what that’s got to do with deciding whom you really love. There’s no way I’m dumping my boyfriend for someone competent.

Even if I agree with how things stand at the end of this book (which to be honest I’m not completely sure I do), I’m sure there must have been a way of working things out that was more convincing, more satisfying and more in keeping with the tone of the rest of the book. And if Matthews wanted something big and dramatic, maybe she could have made the story into a serious story instead of a comedy. It was like something terrible was happening and I was still waiting for the punchline.

Not many of the characters were likeable but I did find them interesting. Ali seemed a bit moany and obsessive and embarrassing but I genuinely wanted things to work out for her and I was interested in how she was going to make changes in her life. Matthews’ writing ensured that even though she was unfaithful pretty much from the start, she wasn’t the villain of the piece. She was just feeling lonely and unloved and then she met someone who made sure she didn’t feel that way anymore.

Ed was even worse. I really feel for the poor kids. He seemed desperate to prove his masculinity and the way he treats Orla and Nicola (and Ali) just isn’t very nice. It doesn’t matter how forceful and determined to get into his pants Orla and Nicola are (in very different ways), it’s still not very nice of him to shag both of them. At least Ali waited until Ed had thrown her out before jumping into bed (or rather into the bath) with Christian. But it was interesting watching Ed trying to work out which one he liked best. It seemed like he changed his mind all the time. Maybe Matthews had to write him this way in order to ensure that Ali didn’t look bad but it was hard to sympathise with him much – although he was certainly very amusing.

Christian was just adorable. He’s sweet and well-meaning but a bit useless. He does do some awful things (really quite seriously awful, not to mention illegal) and he does seem scarily immature for a twenty-three year old, even by my standards. He seems more like a sixteen year old, maybe even younger, who wants to be a grown-up and in some ways has a more grown-up outlook than most people his age but stick him in the grown-up world and he doesn’t have a clue. But his feelings for Ali seem warm, genuine and romantic. He tries really hard to make her happy. It’s just at the same time he’s trying equally hard to make himself happy.

But my favourite character, Sharon, was hardly in it. She was the tart Christian met at the nightclub on the same night that Ali was thrown out by Ed. Sharon is just so amazingly nice and caring. She just wants something to eat and it isn’t even her house but she can tell Ali’s upset so she asks if she’s okay and offers to make her a cup of tea. Even when she realises Ali is essentially her rival for Christian’s affections, Sharon is still really nice to her. And why shouldn’t she be? Nice people come in all shapes and sizes, including as little slags. The other characters in this book could learn a lot from her. And so could I.

It’s funny how little things can annoy you in a book – and often it’s not the writer’s fault at all. At one point, Matthews referred to ‘a turn of turtles’ and I got really excited because I happen to know the collective noun for turtles is a bale of turtles. But I looked it up on Google just in case and unfortunately turn and bale are both correct. So instead of showing off how clever I am for knowing the real collective noun for turtles, I instead look ignorant for only knowing one of the terms. And that’s even more annoying than someone getting it wrong.

Sunday, 28 March 2010

A Compromising Position (Carole Matthews)***

I like Carole Matthews’ way of telling multiple-viewpoint stories. I think she’s the only author I’ve ever found who’s had one first-person narrator and various people in the third person. It works well in the Chocolate Lovers series but it’s even better in this book. Maybe it’s because Emily is such a big character, you get used very early on to the fact that she features both as “I” and “Emily”. In the Chocolate Lovers series, first-person heroine Lucy is barely mentioned in the section from other people’s points of views but Emily is central to everything that goes on in the book.

It took me a while to get to like her. She spends a lot of time early on telling us how her friend Cara really isn’t normal. She does have a point about that. Cara is very New Age and into spells, massage and dreadlocks. But considering Cara has just come to Emily’s rescue by giving her a place to live when her boyfriend posted a saucy picture of her on the Internet, Emily probably should have been nicer about her.

Besides, it’s not as though Emily is so very normal herself. On the very first page of the book, she is wailing like a banshee in public. I might have been more forgiving if she was a natural crybaby but she manages to be very brave for the rest of the book even though her life is full of disasters. So the banshee wailing seems like attention-seeking to me.

Also, while I haven’t really delved into the sex lives of most people I know because I’m really not interested, I shouldn’t imagine most women spend their bedroom time dressing up in Saucy Santa outfits, writing Ho Ho Ho on their bottoms, and allowing their boyfriends to photograph it. She wasn’t to know that he was going to put it on the Internet and that her bottom was going to turn into one of the Internet’s most-viewed pages but still, I think most people wouldn’t do it in the first place. And if I’m wrong about that, I think I’d rather not know about it really.

When Emily says she’s a normal person, it’s difficult not to laugh. When she says she’s organised and competent, I found it hysterical. And then I found out she was a teacher… now I’m not saying teachers don’t or shouldn’t have a sex life but you just can’t take this book seriously.

A Compromising Position is loads of fun and Matthews really keeps you guessing. I had no idea who was going to end up with whom. Emily and Cara are both in love with Adam, whose ex-wife Laura is married to Barry but seems more inclined to share her problems with Adam. Emily’s ex-boyfriend Declan is also keen to get back with Emily, at least when he’s not enticing Cara into someone else’s hot tub.

Then there’s Chris, who is such a total typical lad, I was just waiting for him to fall in love. The fact he insisted on carrying a picture of Emily’s bottom around with him and kissing it made me wonder if he might fall in love with her. I quite fancy him actually. At least he knows what he wants from what girl (though it probably helps that he wants the same thing from all of them) and he’s honest about it. I don’t want to sleep with him though. I just want to look after him. So I’m not sure we’d get on. Then there’s this guy called Sebastian, who has connections to almost all the main characters but they don’t know he knows all of them. If they had known, this book would have been a lot shorter.

It is very funny the way Adam and Emily fall in love with each other at first sight (not that it stops Adam from shagging Cara and worrying about Laura, or Emily from considering taking up with publicist Jonathan Gold) without realising that they kind of know each other already. Adam knows Cara has a friend called Emily whose bottom has been on international news (he has seen a photograph of her but presumably he didn’t really look at her face) and Emily knows Cara fancies a guy at her work called Adam. But then they have a chance meeting in a bar when Emily’s dyed her hair (and isn’t flashing her bottom) and they don’t really talk. They just drool and Adam tells her she has sauce on her nose and Emily is so humiliated, she runs off. They then spend half the book trying to find each other. This does go on a bit long. There’s a limit to how many times Emily and Adam can narrowly miss meeting one another. When Emily finally realises who he is and she decides to jump out of the window in order to avoid meeting him, things really have got a bit silly.

So it’s definitely not a book to take too seriously. It’s quite satisfactory the way all the coupling works out in the end but there’s nothing to tell you these are the ‘right’ characters, or that they’re going to live happily every after. And it’s not all that realistic. Emily might be nice-looking but she’s thirty-two. About ten years older than most successful glamour models. And I’m sure that if I created a website and put my bottom on it, I wouldn’t start earning lots of money from it, like Declan does when he puts Emily’s nether regions on the Net. I’m not even sure how he does manage to earn so much money from it. Is it pay-per-view? Perhaps, but once the national newspapers have got hold of it, and once Chris has forwarded it to his Facebook friends, there’s no need to look at the original.

And it’s also a bit disturbing that Adam takes on a job as a porn photographer in order to prove to Laura that he can look after their son Josh when she goes to Australia to find herself. Josh takes it all in his stride – he seems to know a lot more about glamour models than Adam does – but I’m not sure Laura would be too happy if she knew about it. So Adam’s pretty much deceiving her in order to get custody of Josh, and I don’t think that’s fair. But the rest of the book is so mad, it’s hard to get too uptight over these little problems. I couldn’t ever see Emily, Adam, Cara, Laura, Josh and Sebastian as real people (Chris I believe in apart from the bottom-kissing) so it doesn’t matter what Adam does really. I was amused enough to keep reading but I didn’t care about the characters.

Thursday, 29 October 2009

The Chocolate Lovers' Club (Carole Matthews)****

I read The Chocolate Lovers’ Diet first and really enjoyed it. Then I read the first in the series, The Chocolate Lovers’ Club and I really enjoyed that too. Both are really great comedies, with some really amusing characters and situations, as well as some more serious storylines that nevertheless fit into the book well. There’s just one problem. The two books are pretty much the same.

Yes, the characters and storylines have moved on a little bit between one book and the next and there are differences, but they mostly have exactly the same problem. It’s true that the same problems can hang around for years and it’s not unusual to think you’ve solved one problem, only for it to come back again. In that sense, it’s a realistic book. But you don’t want two stories about the same set of characters to be that much alike.

There are parts of the book that aren’t funny at all. Lucy’s complete and total inability to cope with any kind of job is terrifying. Even I’d have done better than her. I’d have done better with driving that van and I don’t even have a driving licence for a car. And if I’d trashed that bookshop – which I never would have done, at least not to that extent – I wouldn’t run away and leave the whole mess behind for my elderly boss to find when he got back from his hospital appointment. I’d want to, I really would. But you can’t do things like that.

But Lucy is mostly an adorable character. Once the incidents mentioned above are over with and she’s back to her old job and back to sitting at her desk, doing no work at all (she’s much less trouble when she’s doing nothing), you can put your reservations about her out of your mind, and start loving her again.

Then there’s the sex-mad Chantal. Yes, she is incredibly stupid and I wouldn’t blame anyone for calling her a slag. She does have a bit of an obsession. But she too is a very nice person. Nadia is amazing the way she deals with her young son and her husband’s gambling addiction and their money worries, not to mention the fact she still has some strength to spare for providing support for her friends.

Autumn is perhaps a bit too nice but I also think she’s shockingly unprofessional. She runs a craft class to support young people who have been in trouble with the law. It’s very commendable but when Autumn decides to turn to a bit of criminality herself, I can’t help questioning her integrity. Yes, it was in order to help Chantal who had got herself into trouble and was herself the victim of a crime. But that doesn’t make it okay that Autumn should either a) break the law herself or b) let the former criminals she’s supposed to be helping think there are times when it’s okay to do things like that.

The law-breaking section is brilliant though. Very funny and I did kind of wish I was there with them. But it doesn’t make it right.

Sunday, 11 January 2009

Let's Meet on Platform 8 (Carole Matthews)***

I don’t always like stories with stations in. They so seldom seem anything like the real thing. When I read about a station I know well, I often think: this isn’t the Euston/Leicester Square/Barbican I know.

But Carole Matthews gets it right. Her Euston is my Euston. I didn’t know about the pub above the concourse, but it was right where she said it was when I actually looked up. The stations are wonderfully described. Euston, Watford Junction, Leighton Buzzard… I’ve been to those places. It’s so nice to read a book and recognise the stations I know and love and even talk to sometimes... (although maybe I shouldn’t admit to that part).

However, I was a bit surprised to hear that Jamie takes the Northern Line from Euston to Leicester Square, then changes onto the Piccadilly Line to Covent Garden. Doesn’t he know they are ‘officially’ the two closest stations on the Underground network (although Charing Cross and Embankment on the Northern Line are the closest really)? Unless there’s a train actually sitting in the Piccadilly Line platform at Leicester Square when you get there, it’s quicker to walk. And if he does walk, he might be able to avoid the Covent Garden crowds he was moaning about.

But Jamie is a bit of an idiot. If he wasn’t, there wouldn’t be a story at all.

It’s a shame about the characters, really. It starts wonderfully, with Jamie running into Teri (literally) and knocking her over. He looks after her, and they end up chatting, and they really seem to get on well. But then, in a twist of Fate that never happens in Mills and Boon, it turns out Jamie is married. Well, he would be, wouldn’t he? Jamie is short for James! We know what they’re like. In fiction, anyway. See Lucy in the Sky, Holly’s Inbox, Watermelon and Got You Back if you don’t believe me. They’re worse than Matthews (characters called Matthew I mean, not the author of this book). Matthews might be okay if they weren’t so immature. Jamie is one of the nicest Jameses I’ve ever read about, but that doesn’t change the fact they can’t stay faithful to save their lives. (The fact that I’m not very good at being faithful either is irrelevant.)

Teri is nice to start off with, but then she gets a bit caught up in the affair, and she becomes a bit possessive. And seriously, I have no respect for anyone who answers the phone when they’re about to be sick. Obviously, I can see why speaking on the phone is infinitely more attractive as an option, but as far as I can see it, it’s not an option. Just go to the toilet, do what you have to do, then dial 1471 and call the person back. And don’t go into details of why you couldn’t answer the phone 5 minutes ago. Even a non-emetophobe probably won’t enjoy that sort of detail.

Okay? Now onto more pleasant subjects. Like adultery.

Let’s Meet on Platform 8 is a very brave story. There is a lot of adultery in fiction, but there are few novels where everyone involved – the adulterer, the spouse and the bit on the side – are all basically nice people. Usually, at least one of them is a clearly defined villain, and they are horrible in all sorts of other ways too (see A Crowded Marriage, Watermelon etc). So the adultery is a positive thing in that it frees up the heroine to find someone nice instead. Or in something like Getting Rid of Matthew, the guy might not strictly be a villain, but you don’t really want him to end up with either of his women because they both deserve better.

There’s no villain here. Jamie is probably correct when he tells Teri that his wife Pamela doesn’t understand him, but Pamela is still a nice and generally very understanding person – it just so happens her marriage needs a bit of work. Teri and Jamie are also lovely until they make the decision to turn friendly cups of coffee into a shagathon. There’s nothing wrong with a bit of flirtation: in this case, it’s very sweet. But there’s no need to bonk everyone you fancy. If I did that, I’d have no time to write book reviews and I’d probably be dead by now.

It’s easier to stay sympathetic to all parties here than in most books, but the book is still not completely successful. You really want to be torn between what Pamela wants; what Jamie wants; what Teri wants. Supporting one person one minute, then changing your mind; hoping it can somehow work out for everyone in a realistic and non-contrived sort of way. But it’s probably really difficult to write a book like this: Matthews does come pretty close. But if you want to read a Matthews book, read the Chocolate Lovers series. It’s not always realistic but it is nearly always funny.

Saturday, 13 December 2008

The Chocolate Lovers' Diet (Carole Matthews)****

Carole Matthews opens The Chocolate Lovers’ Diet by saying I’m a bitch.

Bitches, apparently, are people who can’t eat whole Mars Bars, or more than one square of dark chocolate at a time. That’s definitely me. Half a Mars bar or one square of dark chocolate makes me feel sick. As I have emetophobia, it’s quite a big thing for me to be eating chocolate at all, but I still have about four squares of milk chocolate a day. So I can’t be all that bitchy. (It’s not for weight reasons after all. If I ate a whole bar of chocolate every day, I’d probably get thinner. And then I really would be a bitch.)

Yes, I know I was complaining when Dorothy Koomson’s The Chocolate Run was all about chocolate, but this is different. The way in which Lucy, Chantal, Autumn and Nadia go mad over chocolate seems quite reasonable to me, and the girls do have plenty of other outside interests. There isn’t a surplus of film-talk, and all sex scenes (except those involving Lucy’s parents) are done in the best possible taste.

And you can’t really blame these women for needing quite as much chocolate as they do. When you read it, you’ll see what I mean. Crises seem to follow them around. To work; to their parents’ houses; to their weddings. Some of these crises are hilarious: Matthews is a wonderful comic writer. But she doesn’t get much chance to show it because a lot of this book is quite sad. Just because the central characters are totally insane, particularly Lucy, it’s easy to get caught up into thinking this book is a comedy. And then something awful happens, just when you’re not expecting it, and then it all gets worse and worse.

If you’re looking for realism, this might not be the book for you - but, on the other hand, I usually look for realism, and I loved it. Most authors who try to pull anything even vaguely unrealistic hear all about it from me in this blog. But Matthews gets away with it. Her book is just too much fun (apart from the sad bits) for me to care that they should all have been arrested. Besides, they’ve been through so much, you feel it’s time they had a bit of crazy fun.

The Chocolate Lovers’ Diet has some great characters. It’s a bit hard to imagine how the girls became friends, as chocolate seems to be the only thing they have in common, but it’s very easy to believe they’re genuinely close. Lucy is no more intelligent than you’d expect from a fictional girl with that name, and her boyfriend Aiden shares with Aidan from Anybody Out There the bad habit of disappearing when his girlfriend needs him (although both have a very good reason). Chantal is a surprisingly respectable sex addict; Autumn an upper-class hippie, and Nadia a woman of amazing courage and kindness. But they do care about each other. Even chocolate comes a poor second.

There are sections told from the points of view from all four women, but, unusually, Lucy’s is told in the first person (and in the present tense and the others in the third person (past tense). This did mean I felt closer to Lucy than the other characters, but that wasn’t really a problem. If you met the Chocolate Lovers for real, Lucy is probably the one you’d get close to first. Lucy is the comedy character, providing relief when everyone else’s life is falling apart, and often just failing to notice that her own is doing the same. Without her, Nadia’s, Autumn’s and Chantal’s stories would have been so much darker, and, while it might have been a more powerful book, it wouldn’t have been half as fun. We know that chocolate can’t really cure all these problems, but it’s nice to pretend it does.

Maybe the book gets a bit slushy at the end, but that’s only to be expected when there’s a chocolate fountain spraying everywhere.

This is the second of two books, but I read this one first and it works very well as a stand-alone book.